Most North Texas homes heat with a gas furnace and cool with a separate central AC, but a heat pump can do both jobs with one system. Here is how the two setups differ and what to ask before choosing.
The two common setups
The first is the pairing many homes already have: a central air conditioner for summer and a gas furnace for winter, sharing one set of ducts and one thermostat. The AC has an outdoor condenser and an indoor evaporator coil, and the furnace burns natural gas to heat the air. They are separate machines that share an air handler or blower.
The second is an air-source heat pump. ENERGY STAR describes air-source heat pumps as moving heat rather than generating it: they pull heat from outdoor air into the home in winter and remove heat from the home in summer, so a ducted unit works like a central air conditioner that runs in reverse for whole-house heating. In summer, a heat pump and a standard AC do the same job, and the outdoor unit looks much alike. The difference appears in winter.
How the climate shapes the choice
NWS Fort Worth normals for DFW show a normal January low of about 36 degrees F and an average of roughly 29 days per year with a low at or below freezing. Winters are generally mild, with periodic cold fronts bringing brief below-normal stretches, and the average freeze-free period runs from March to November. The same normals show normal July and August highs of about 96 degrees F and roughly 20 days a year at 100 degrees or higher.
That is a cooling-dominated climate. The system works hardest from late spring into fall, and the heating season is shorter. For a heat pump, a mild winter is the easier case, because it pulls heat from outdoor air that is not extremely cold. For a gas furnace, a short season means it sits idle much of the year. Occasional hard freezes and ice storms still happen, though, and it is worth asking how any heat pump you consider will heat the house on the coldest nights. Some include backup electric heat strips for that purpose.
Comparing the options
| Question | AC plus gas furnace | Heat pump |
|---|---|---|
| Equipment | Two systems sharing ducts | One outdoor unit and an air handler |
| Fuel | Electric for cooling, natural gas for heat | Electric for both |
| Gas line needed | Yes | No |
| Combustion safety issues | Yes, with a furnace | None from the heat pump itself |
| Cold nights | Furnace heats on its own | Depends on the model and backup heat |
| Summer cooling | Central AC | Works like a central AC |
What each costs, as published
These ranges come from published cost guides, not from quotes, and your house will differ. A Texas price guide from HVAC.com, covering a 2,000 square foot home with a 3-ton system, lists about $3,800 to $4,500 for a central AC replacement and about $6,000 to $8,000 for a 3-ton heat pump installation with an air handler. The same guide puts an 80 percent AFUE, 50,000 BTU furnace replacement at about $3,000. National figures from Fixr list heat pump installation at about $4,000 to $11,000 and central AC installation at about $5,000 to $12,000. HomeGuide, also national, lists furnace replacement at about $2,000 to $5,400.
Notice that replacing an AC and a furnace together adds up to a number near a heat pump installation. If both the AC and furnace are near the end of their lives, a heat pump replaces two purchases with one. If only one has failed, the decision is simpler: replace that part. Our guide on repair versus replacement covers the age and cost factors.
When a gas furnace and AC still make sense
- Your furnace works well and is not old, and only the AC needs attention. Replacing just the AC is usually the lower-cost step.
- You want gas heat during the coldest nights and are comfortable with the gas bill.
- Your home already has gas service and a furnace sized for the ductwork.
If you stay with gas, keep the safety basics in mind. If you smell gas, leave the building, call 911, and call the gas utility from outside. For most towns around here that is Atmos Energy at 866-322-8667. Weatherford, Willow Park, Hudson Oaks and Aledo are served by Texas Gas Service at 800-959-5325. Our guide, furnace smells like gas, covers the steps. The Consumer Product Safety Commission recommends CO alarms on every level of the home and outside sleeping areas, not above fuel-burning appliances, and says an alarm is no substitute for proper upkeep of appliances that can produce CO. It advises having the heating system professionally inspected and serviced annually.
When a heat pump is worth a look
- Both your AC and your furnace are old, and you are replacing the whole system anyway.
- You have no gas service, or you want to avoid adding a gas line.
- You are adding cooling and heating to a space without ductwork, where a ductless unit may fit. Our ductless mini-split guide covers that case.
A heat pump also works as the cooling system for the long summer, so it earns its keep on the side of the year that matters most here. If you want to compare approaches, our heat pump installation page and furnace replacement page describe what a call involves.
Comfort, ducts and the attic
Whichever system you choose, the ductwork decides how well it performs. Many slab homes in this area have the air handler or furnace in the attic or a closet, with supply ducts running through attic space that gets very hot in summer. A heat pump or furnace connected to leaky or poorly insulated ducts wastes part of its output before the air reaches a room. A company that quotes a new system should look at the ducts, the return air path and the size of the existing openings, not just the outdoor unit.
Sizing matters as well. An oversized system cools quickly, shuts off and leaves the house damp and uneven, while an undersized one runs all afternoon without catching up. Ask how a company arrived at the size it recommends. A sound answer refers to the home's insulation, windows, orientation and duct layout, not only to the square footage or the size of the old unit.
Thermostat and backup heat
A heat pump that has electric backup heat strips will use them when outdoor temperatures fall far enough or when the system needs help recovering from a setback. Big overnight setbacks can trigger the strips and raise the bill, so a steady setting is usually easier on both comfort and cost. If you are considering a heat pump, ask how the thermostat controls the switch between the heat pump and the backup, and whether a new thermostat is part of the job.
Service needs after the install
A heat pump runs in both seasons, so it has more run hours than a plain AC, and its maintenance matters through the year. Filters, coils and the outdoor unit need regular attention. A local company can handle heat pump repair and routine service. If your system is a gas furnace and AC, the same company may service both, and annual furnace checks are worth scheduling before cold weather.
Questions to ask before you decide
- Is my ductwork in good shape and sized for the new equipment? Leaky or undersized ducts undercut any system. See ductwork repair and replacement.
- How will the system heat the house on the coldest nights, and does it have backup heat?
- Will the work be done under a mechanical permit, and who pulls it? Fort Worth has permit rules for replacements, and nearby towns have their own offices.
- Which refrigerant does the new unit use, and is that equipment compliant with EPA rules? See our guide to refrigerants and leaks.
- Does the company hold a TDLR air conditioning and refrigeration contractor license? Use TDLR's license search, and read how in our guide to checking a TDLR license.
Get quotes from more than one independent company, since equipment, installation quality and ductwork conditions differ. Homes in Grapevine, Cleburne and the other towns on our service areas page all face the same hot-summer, mild-winter pattern.
AC Repair Fort Worth is a free referral service. We are not an HVAC company, we do not sell equipment, and the company you reach sets its own pricing.
Frequently asked questions
Does a heat pump work in North Texas winters?
Is a heat pump the same as a central AC?
Can I keep my gas furnace and just replace the AC?
How much does a heat pump cost compared to an AC?
Sources
Last updated: